Thursday, April 19, 2007

Imagine a fairy tale country that has a government based on freedom, democracy and basic human rights for all.Now, imagine that to prepare that country’s children for the rights and responsibilitiesof living in and contributing to the free, democratic society, the government institutes a strange practice:Beginning at the age of 5, children in the country are confined for 13 years as hostages to a totalitarian institutionrun as a dictatorship.In that institution, children’s movement and bodily functions are controlled and regimented.Children cannot get out of seats or out of rooms without permission.Calls to parents are forbidden except in emergencies.Children have no right to question the validity of the curriculum, no right to critical thinking in deviance to the teacher’s agenda,no right to dispute or influence procedures for maintaining order and guidance.Children have no right to a curriculum based on independent study,or to have honored their own learning styles and educational needs and goals.The children can only go out and get exercise for 10-20 minutes once or twice per day,but that stops totally around the age of 10.Children are taught that the democracy exists, but are not allowed to take part in it.At the age of 18, children in that country are released.They are expected to be ready to function in society, advanced education and careersas self-motivating, free-thinking, innovative and assertive individuals.Now imagine that this fairy tale is not a fairy tale, but the very real state of the American Educational Institution for the past 100 years.

DARTH BLUEJAY

1 comment:

Naffel said...

Perhaps my situation is atypical, but I got to have a fair amount of say in my schooling. I mean, in history class we made swords out of PVC pipe and duct tape and beat the tar out of each other. It was a teacher sponsored event. We got to pick our own labs in physics and chemistry...

I quickly got the feeling that enthusiasm bought us more freedom than your typical classroom.

That said, I was allowed to go to the bathroom when ever I felt like it. I was allowed to leave the room to stretch...

I am loath to begin thinking of the battles I expect to have with faculty once my children start school, but I have a feeling that my excellent experience is going to infuse my thinking with an undue bias.